Instant download. Print tonight. Solve tonight.

Tonight Instead
The Second Card, Case No. 021

The Second Card — Case No. 021

$19

Instant PDF · nothing ships

Printable PDF case file · instant download · print at home · nothing is shipped

Sixteen years after she was presumed drowned, Jo Tolbrook phoned the sheriff's office from New Zealand. So who left her car at the lake?

Michigan, February 2008. A car stands in the ice-fishing lot, her camera is in the glove box, and its card holds sunset pictures. The whole town mourned Jo Tolbrook. In 2024 she phoned the sheriff's office from New Zealand, alive, and asked one question: did her mother mean it?

The Second Card is a printable mystery case file for two to four people around a table, or one determined solver. Reopen the cold case with the old file and the papers no one gathered in 2008:

  • a town map and a marina plan;
  • a snowplow ticket and an alarm log;
  • a camera's file-properties printout;
  • bowling printouts;
  • a shoebox of returned valentines.

Jo says she never went near the lake. Someone left that car there. Work out who, when, and why.

Six worksheets and a checkpoint keep you on track. A hint ladder is there if you stall. A separate, sealed solution walks through every step and names the exhibit that proves it. No one dies in this case. You need no technical knowledge: the file explains the camera data, the alarm log and the snowplow. Download it and print at home; nothing is shipped.

At a glance

  • Format: Digital PDF — nothing ships. Instant download. Print at home on US Letter, single-sided, at 100%.
  • Players: 1 to 4
  • Play time: 120 to 150 minutes
  • Pages: Case file 52 pages, plus a separate 7-page solution PDF (S1–S7)
  • Difficulty: Standard, 3 of 5. For couples who have solved a case before, or a small group.
  • Inside: 24 exhibits, 11 identity cards, a town map and a marina plan, 6 worksheets, 1 checkpoint, 1 verdict sheet, and a hint ladder (six puzzles, three rungs each)
  • Content: No one dies in this case. A woman everyone believed drowned is alive.
  • Needs: No outside knowledge. Every rule is printed in the file, and p. 4 has a short glossary.

Questions

  • Is anything shipped? No. Digital PDF — nothing ships. You download it and print it at home on US Letter.
  • How many can play? 1 to 4.
  • How long does it take? Plan on 120 to 150 minutes.
  • Is it a murder mystery? No. No one dies in this case.
  • Do I need to know about cameras or alarms? No. The file explains everything a solver needs, and p. 4 has a short glossary.
  • What if we get stuck? Use the hint ladder on page 51. The sealed solution explains every step.

After you pay: your download link appears on the order confirmation page and is emailed to you.
Download missing or a file won't open? Email hello@tonightinstead.com with your order number and we'll resend or replace it, usually the same day. All sales are final (see our refund policy).

$19

Instant PDF · print in colour · all sales final